Archaeological Myths and Misconceptions
Because of former archaeological practices, misrepresentation in the media,
and long-time stereotypes about people of the past, people often have inaccurate
ideas about what archaeologists do and the societies that they
study.
Myth: People Used To Hunt
Dinosaurs
Reality: Dinosaurs died out 65 million years ago.
Fully modern humans (Homo sapiens sapiens) have existed for about 100,000 years,
and they have occupied the Americas for at least 15,000 years. These first
inhabitants hunted "megafauna" (big animals) such as mammoths and mastodons, and
they also gathered plants. But no people ever hunted
dinosaurs.
Myth: Archaeologists Dig Up
Dinosaurs.
Reality: Although both "palenotology" and
"archaeology" mean knowledge of "old things," paleontology is the study of the
life of past geologic ages through examination of fossil remains of ancient
plants and animals. Archaeologists study people of the past through their
material remains. Archaeology is a branch of anthropology, which is the study of
humans. Archaeology is a method for therecovery, study, and reconstruction of
thepast of humans through analysis of their material remains. Archaeologists in
their study of artifacts have called upon paleontologists, as well as botanists,
soil specialists, and geologists, to aid in their
analysis.
Myth: Archaeologists And "Pot Hunters" Share
The Same Goals.
Reality: Pot hunters are collectors of
prehistoric Indian artifacts for personal gain or private pleasure; they
generally have little or no interest in the scientific interpretation of what is
recovered. Archaeologists, both amateur and professional , keep careful,
complete records and share their conclusions with others; their goal is to
contribute as much as possible to our knowledge about the culture and lifestyle
of a prehistoric people.
Myth:
All A Person Needs To
Practice Archaeology Is A Shovel And A Place To
Dig.
Reality: Professional archaeologists undergo many
years of academic training, as well as experience in the field and laboratory.
Moreover, today's archaeology involves more time spent in the laboratory
classifying and analyzing the material recovered than time spent in the field at
an excavation site.
Myth: Archaeologists Spend All Of
Their Time Digging.
Reality: Archaeology is more than a
dig. Archaeologists actually spend a relatively small amount of their time
excavating, compared to the time spent in the laboratory, analyzing and
interpreting their finds, and preparing written reports about the project.
Moreover, some professional archaeologists are involved in the management and
protection of cultural resources and so therefore may spend little time doing
excavation.
Myth: Archaeologists Prefer To Excavate
Graves.
Reality: The study of human remains from an
archaeological site can provide important details about the diet and health of a
population. However, such excavations are delicate and time consuming, as is the
conservation and disposition of the remains after their recovery. For these
reasons, as well as respect for cultural sensitivities regarding deceased
ancestors, archaeologists think carefully before unearthing a burial. In
addition, federal laws protect the graves of Native
Americans.
Myth: Archaeologists Get To Keep Any
Valuable Artifacts That They Find.
Reality: Professional
archaeologists do not keep, buy, sell, or trade any artifacts. They believe that
objects recovered from a site should be kept together as a collection so as to
be available for future study or display. By law, artifacts recovered from
federal or state lands belong to the public and must be maintained on behalf of
the public.
Myth: The Typical Archaeologist Is Trying
To Find Beautiful, Valuable Objects For Display Or
Sale.
Reality: The caricature of the archaeologist as the
bearded fellow in the pith helmet rifling ancient tombs dies hard--witness
"Raiders of the Lost Ark." However, most archaeologists are more concerned with
using the physical remains of past peoples as tools in reconstructing the
lifeways of those people than in the artifacts themselves. A charred grain of
corn from an ancient hearthfire may be the most valuable item recovered from a
site.
Myth: It's Okay To Pick Up Artifacts Because If
You Don't, Someone Else Will. Besides, The Site Won't Last Long
Anyway.
Reality: Removing artifacts without using proper
scientific methods destroys evidence. This is what pot hunters and surface
collectors do. Archaeological sites do not have to be excavated and actually
survive best if left untouched. In addition, federal and state laws prohibit the
removal of artifacts from public lands without a
permit.
Myth: Archaeologists Investigate Mainly
Prehistoric Sites.
Reality: Archaeology is the scientific
study of non-renewable and often fragile material remains of past human
activity. Archaeologists excavate on land and under the water to recover
evidence with which to reconstruct and describe past culture, technology, and
behavior. This past can be as long ago as 14,000 years ago or as recent as 20
years ago. Archaeologists investigate the villages of native peoples and the
house sites of early pioneers. They investigate the stone outcrops where
prehistoric peoples quarried raw materials for their tools, and iron furnaces
where historic peoples smelted iron for theirs'. They investigate where native
peoples threw their trash as well as rural and urban dumps where historic
peoples threw out their trash. The age of artifacts does not matter; it is the
way in which they are interpreted to inform us about trhe past that makes the
archaeology.